The FCC argued that Starlink’s speed tests showed it could not reliably provide the necessary high-speed internet. Additionally, the proposal required users to purchase a $600 dish to start using the service. FCC Chair Jessica Rosenworcel reaffirmed the decision, emphasizing that Starlink’s data failed to meet both uplink and downlink speed standards. Elon Musk, CEO of SpaceX, has called the decision “illegal” and criticized the FCC for denying the funding. He believes that Starlink could have made a significant difference, even stating that it “could have saved lives” in North Carolina during Hurricane Helene. Despite Musk’s objections, the FCC remains firm on its position.